By Ademola Rabiu
- A PhD in Staging Sneers
- Bile, with a byline
- Facts She Admits, Then Buries
- The Choreography of Contempt
- The Burning She Didn’t Write About
- The Akara Woman as Prop
- Performative Rage, Zero Cost
- Competitive Egoism, Better Punctuation
- The House Negro Pose
- The Market for Contempt
- “Punch” Should Ask Itself
- The Short Answer
She calls Fani-Kayode choleric. She calls Tinubu enfeebled, empty-headed, and heartless. But she has no word for the burning of Africans in South Africa. This is not criticism. It is a pose. And the pose is getting old. An expert in dance and theatre. Her columns read like both: choreographed performances, staged for an audience that already knows its lines.
There is a certain kind of Nigerian columnist who has read just enough to weaponise culture, but not enough to be burdened by ideas, convictions or a distinct ideology. Going by her two recent outings in The Punch, Abimbola Adelakun has perfected the act. I have to read “The enfeebled President limits his campaign” (October 22, 2026) and “Fani-Kayode’s ego trip to South Africa” (November 19, 2026) twice.
The column presents them as criticisms. One claims to weigh His Excellency Chief Femi Fani-Kayode’s fitness for his posting in South Africa. The other claims to assess President Bola Tinubu’s re-election campaign and his mental and intellectual capacity to lead. Read them as criticism and both collapse. What is left is something else entirely: the public vivisection of men the writer had already convicted before she typed the first sentence.
Sadly, both mistake personal sneering for public intellectualism. Neither offers rigorous policy analysis or diplomatic context. Instead, both rely on tired insults, clinical slurs, and a sweeping contempt for Nigeria and Africa. The subjects differ. The language, the condescending style, never does. One week it is Bola Tinubu’s stamina, his mental and intellectual capacity. The following week, it is Femi Fani-Kayode’s ego. Different men, different offices, same verdict handed down before the evidence is even gathered. Both use the same trick: asking the reader to feel superior rather than to think. That is not intellectualism. It is a signature.
Let us be precise. The trouble is not that Adelakun is wrong. The trouble is that she is not trying to be right. She is trying to be cutting. She is trying to be the cleverest person in the room. And she is willing to flatten facts, motives, and context to get there. It is a choreography of contempt. Every sentence knows its mark. Every paragraph hits its cue.
A PhD in Staging Sneers
Perhaps the education explains it. Maybe the filth of mind has an innocent explanation: training. Abimbola Adelakun holds a doctorate in theatre and dance. I do not mock the degree; I cite it because it explains her writings. They are not arguments. They are performances, complete with blocking and stage directions: a protagonist (herself), a villain (whoever is in the news that week), and an audience that arrived already convinced. The curtain rises. The sneer drops. The applause comes from people who agreed before the first line. The curtain falls. The villain changes weekly. And what remains? Nothing built. Nothing taught. Nothing corrected. Only the echo of people who came to boo, and a set struck before dawn.
She did not write two cerebral pieces about Fani-Kayode and Tinubu. She staged two shows. The pity is that the opinion page is not a theatre, and the reader is not a ticket holder. Some of us came for the argument. She gave us choreography.
And here is the strangest fact in the whole affair, the one that reframes everything else. Abimbola Adelakun is not merely a Punch columnist. She is an Associate Professor of Global Christianity at the University of Chicago Divinity School. A scholar of Pentecostalism, performance and religion. The author of a book called, of all things, “Powerful Devices: The Politics and Praxis of Spiritual Warfare.” One would expect a student of faith and teacher of divinity to know what contempt does to a people. Her Thursday column suggests otherwise.
Bile, with a byline
Now the first piece, the one about the “enfeebled President.” PBAT’s head, we are told, is “as empty as his heart.” Not “appears empty.” Not “I suspect.” Declared flatly, as though she has held the head in her hands and weighed it. On what evidence? None offered. The campaign remarks the whole jejune stands on is, by her own admission, impossible to confirm or deny, so she simply pronounces it “likely fabricated.” When facts will not cooperate, the columnist supplies verdicts.
She couldn’t even stay onside with her own newsroom. While her column mourned a president too feeble to campaign, the news pages around it carried the report: Tinubu expands 2027 campaign itinerary to 19 states. The columnist declared a funeral; her own newsroom was reporting a mobilisation. Being contradicted by your own front page is awkward. But to be contradicted by the related-news box on your own article! It is just that consistency has never been the point. Verdicts are the point.
In her latest piece, on Chief Fani-Kayode, our High Commissioner in South Africa, the standard drops further. Diplomacy is a legitimate subject. An ambassador’s approach is a legitimate subject. A man’s marriage bed is not a subject, and has never been a subject, of public affairs. Yet there it sits, in the middle of a column about foreign relations: the wife, the domestic spats. Ask what that sentence is doing there. It is doing the only job it can do. It is there to denigrate. Then the garnish. Achebe’s madman, Nwibe, is fetched out of a short story so His Excellency can be certified “aláwòkù,” a sick man whose madness still clings to him. The writer professes rage on behalf of Nigerians in South Africa whose welfare might suffer from all this. The compassion is costume. A person genuinely worried about Nigerians abroad does not spend that worry mocking our sitting Envoy. She spends it on the only thing that matters in the paragraph: the sound of her own cruelty.
Worse still is her selective framing of the diplomatic incident in Pretoria. She calls our High Commissioner “choleric” before she has established a single fact. She mocks him for “breaking things apart” within a day. But what actually happened? Chief Fani-Kayode’s introduction and speech were cut from the livestream. Arguably, another diplomat might have chosen to handle the exclusion through back channels. That is a fair argument, but Adelakun does not make it. She writes backwards from insult: she decides he is a “temperamental fiend,” then arranges the facts around that verdict. That is not criticism. It is caricature, theatre in which the playwright has already decided who the fool is.
Facts She Admits, Then Buries
And notice what she does with the facts she herself admits. She admits that Nigerian stations recorded the ceremony. She admits that Chief Fani-Kayode could have shared their footage instead of ranting. Fine. But she uses those admissions not to illuminate the situation, but to sharpen her sneer. The whole piece circles one question: what is so earth-shaking about what you have to say? That is a question about ego, not diplomacy. It lets her avoid the harder question. Was the exclusion deliberate? Did the South African Presidency handle the ceremony with the courtesy owed to Africa’s largest economy? Adelakun does not ask. She is not interested. She has a character to assassinate, and she gets on with it.
When a host state’s national broadcaster cuts off a foreign envoy’s remarks during a formal credentials ceremony, defending national visibility and institutional dignity is not an “ego trip.” It is a legitimate concern, one that the Nigerian High Commission itself officially flagged as a breach of protocol. By siding reflexively against Nigeria’s mission and advising our envoy to swallow slights quietly, lest he upset his hosts, Adelakun champions a posture of timid subservience disguised as sophistication.
This reflex is not accidental. It runs through her October 22 column on President Bola Tinubu, where legitimate debate over campaign strategy and governance quickly descends into crude ageism and physical mockery. In the Tinubu column, the President’s inner life is pronounced empty, with no demonstration offered. She scolds Fani-Kayode for a factual error, then corrects him with “it was the SABC that supposedly did.” Supposedly. Precision for him, conjecture for her. The High Commission states its position on record, and her rebuttal is two words: “I disagree.” She disagrees – She that must be obeyed. She that knows all things.
Ramaphosa Did the Right Thing (And She Can’t Say It)
But here is what actually happened while Adelakun was polishing her sneer. President Cyril Ramaphosa did the right thing on the spot. He did not wave the matter away. He called the SABC anchor. He asked her, audibly, to correct the mistake. He directed Chief Fani-Kayode to Sophie Mokoena, the broadcaster’s acting political and foreign editor, so the matter could be addressed properly. And the South African Presidency published the full video of the ceremony on its website. The full recording was uploaded to the Presidency’s YouTube page hours after the protest. The footage included Fani-Kayode’s complete address. That is what a serious government does. It corrects the record. It does not sneer from a safe distance. It acts.
We know asking her for patriotism or basic national pride is asking for too much. Her worldview is shaped by proximity to Western corridors – complete with a cousin in the UK Parliament – that treat everything Nigerian, African, and Black as backward and irredeemable. History already has a name for that mindset: the “house Negro” reflex, eager to validate foreign contempt against one’s own people. Serious columnists argue from a clear ideological framework, propose workable alternatives, and respect the agency of the societies they critique. Adelakun’s prose offers none of that. Try to reconstruct an Adelakun doctrine from these two essays, and you will find nothing. No principle that survives a change of subject.
The Choreography of Contempt
Try to reconstruct an Adelakun doctrine from these two essays, and you will find nothing. No principle that survives a change of subject.
Here is the first test she fails. Reverse the names. Had the envoy been a man she favoured, the same temper would have been praised as fearlessness, as a refreshingly commendable refusal to be doormatted abroad. If the tired president were her candidate, the same fatigue would have been recast as statesmanlike restraint. Nothing in either column survives the swap. And that is how you know there is no conviction in the room. Conviction holds when the names change. Her prose collapses the moment they do. What remains is not ideology. It is targeting. That is why every factual wobble is papered over with insult. Agbero. Fiend. Swine. Deadwood. When the argument is thin, the adjectives must do the bleeding.
Here is the second test. Take her piece on His Excellency Chief Femi Fani-Kayode: Adelakun lectures the envoy on diplomatic decorum while violating every rule of responsible commentary herself. This is the columnist who lectures an envoy on diplomatic language, then reaches for schoolyard nouns in the next paragraph. She dredges up private marital disputes, weaponises past health struggles, and hurls labels like “swine” and “aláwòkù” at a sitting diplomat. She demands decorum from a man she calls, in a national newspaper, a tout and ill-tempered.
Her prose does not even trust the reader to catch the insult. It annotates itself, like a bad comedian explaining the joke. Journalists who fawn, she writes, are “respectful (read: pliant).” She has to translate her own sneer in brackets, in case the mob misses it. Cruelty this eager is rarely confident. It is needy. It is innate.
Then watch her launder the cruelty through fake fairness. “We cannot fault him for his [President Tinubu] biological destiny, but…” Everything before the “but” is staged mercy. Everything after it is the knife. “Sincerely, I am not so bothered that Fani-Kayode will be looked on… as an aláwòkù,” she writes, right before spending a whole paragraph doing exactly the bothering. The performance of generosity is just the wrapping. The gift inside is always contempt.
One does not have to endorse every tweet from the High Commissioner to recognise the hypocrisy of a ghonk, a columnist condemning another person’s lack of restraint while indulging in gutter-level name-calling.
And the continent gets its own paragraph of it. Not content with sneering Chief Fani-Kayode and President Tinubu, she widens her brush to sneer at the entire continent. Writing off Africa with the lazy sigh, “Yes, that is Africa for you,” she writes. “Nothing on this continent is ever straight.” Stop and read that again. A Nigerian columnist, paid by a Nigerian newspaper, read mostly by Nigerians, has just told her own audience that nothing in their continent works. Not one government. Not one system. All of it crooked. And the voters? Their crime was voting while African. She cannot even grant them that.
This is not criticism. It is contempt, typeset. And it is not analysis. It is racism dressed up as insight, the posture of a spectator who has mistaken cynicism for wisdom. Africans do not need to be told, from a perch of contempt, that our politics is hopeless. We never abandon Africa; we build there, and we are done being the punchline.
Funny how she never writes “that is America for you.” Not when an American president calls mail-in ballots rigged and then mails in his own. Not when his party redraws maps mid-decade to keep power it did not earn. Not when federal agents gun citizens down in Minneapolis streets. America gets the benefit of the doubt. But Mother Africa? She gets the sneer. Her cynicism, you see, has a visa. It only travels one way – away from Uncle Tom!
Our patriots get the same treatment. When Shehu Sani and others cheered the envoy, she graded them rather than argued with them. They “seem to have confused the nature of international diplomacy,” she sniffed. The write-up never engages a single Nigerian who disagrees with it. It only ranks them. This is the third tell: she does not write to persuade her countrymen. She writes to grade and degrade them, and the grade is always failure.
The Burning She Didn’t Write About
And there is a bigger crime than a cut livestream. It is the burning. It is the killing of innocent Africans in South Africa. It is the global uproar that followed. Those charred bodies were not a vibe. That blood was not a talking point. All true Africans owed those killed a duty to speak and act so the horrendous killing stops. Fani-Kayode chose that task. Nigeria chose that task. They chose diplomatic tools. That is what serious countries do. They do not sneer from a safe distance. They engage, they protest, they negotiate, they protect their citizens.
So will Aunt Tom now say that everyone else is wrong and only she is right? Will she say Ramaphosa was wrong to correct the error, Nigeria was wrong to protest, the global uproar was wrong, and only her column is correct? That is the posture of the professional critic who has turned contempt into a business model.
The Akara Woman as Prop
This is the core of her intellectual hollowness. She is a professional critic in the worst sense. Her stock-in-trade is contempt. She looks at the woman frying akara by the roadside and sees not agency, not resilience, but a “sordid prop in a narrative of state failure.” She looks at small-scale enterprise and sees a trap.
She looks at Nigeria and sees only a catalogue of disappointments. A half-emptied cup. And because she writes from the safe distance of an American university, she can afford to be purity itself. She never has to choose. She never has to build. She never has to be responsible for anything except the elegance of her own despair.
Performative Rage, Zero Cost
This is not conviction. It is a pose. It is performative rage. It is rage that costs the writer nothing. It is intellectual vanity masquerading as moral clarity. And the tragedy is that this pose has a constituency. There are readers who mistake her sneer for rigour, her cynicism for clarity, her nihilism for honesty. They do not notice that she offers no way out. They do not notice that her writings are not corrective, not educative, not even informative in any meaningful sense. They are simply acts of demolition, performed with a thesaurus and a sense of superiority. The PhD in theatre was not wasted. She knows how to stage a scene. She just forgot to write a play.
Competitive Egoism, Better Punctuation
Some readers say she has gone too far by going personal. I would put it differently. She has gone too far by going empty. The Tinubu piece is not a critique of power. It is a performance of disdain for power, staged for an audience that already agrees. The Fani-Kayode piece is not a corrective to his ego. It is an exercise in competitive egoism, a writer showing that she can be just as contemptuous as the man in her imagination she is writing about, only with better punctuation. Neither piece asks the reader to think. Both ask the reader to feel: to feel superior, to feel disgusted, to feel confirmed in the comfortable belief that everyone in public life is either a fool or a knave.
The House Negro Pose
There is a kind of self-hatred that passes for sophistication in certain diaspora circles. It is the belief that Africa is only interesting as a site of failure. It is the belief that the African critic earns her stripes by being more disgusted than everyone else. Adelakun writes from that place. She is the diaspora shallow academic who derides Africa and calls it analysis. She derides Nigeria and calls it honesty. She derides public figures and calls it courage. But courage without conviction is just noise. And noise, however elegantly punctuated, is still noise. It is a soliloquy in an empty theatre.
She teaches the world about African religion from a tenured chair in Chicago. Then she tells Africans, in print, that nothing on their continent is ever straight. Those that departed have every right to leave. I also did more than a decade ago. But there is a special posture of many emigrant intellectuals: certifying the rottenness of the homeland from ten thousand miles away, as though distance were a diagnosis and contempt were a credential.
Notice what the posture costs. Nothing. She can be as disgusted as she likes and still collect the salary. She can deride the country that produced her and still be paid to explain its religions. She can announce that nothing in Africa is ever upright while sitting in a chair built on African tuition, African labour, and African patience. That is not analysis. That is a posture. It is the house-negro pose dressed in academic robes. But the house-negro posture is not courage. It is performance. It is a way of being safely disappointed in everything while standing for nothing.
The Market for Contempt
This is not journalism. It is not even an argument. It is the intellectual equivalent of a sneer in a crowded room. And the fact that it appears in a major newspaper, week after week, says something not just about Adelakun, but about the market for contempt in Nigerian public discourse. She has found her niche. She has found her brand. And she will keep writing these pieces, not because she has something to say, but because she has a tone to sustain. The show must go on.
“Punch” Should Ask Itself
The Punch should ask itself a simple question. Is this criticism? Or is this brand maintenance? Because there is a difference between a columnist who challenges power and a columnist who has turned contempt into a business model. Adelakun is talented. That is what makes it worse. She could write. She could teach. She could argue. Instead, she sneers. And the sneer is not an argument. It never was. It is a dance. And we have seen the steps before.
None of this would matter much if the targets did not deserve scrutiny. They do. Chief Fani-Kayode’s method is a fair subject. Tinubu’s record is a fair subject. The facts are publicly available. She held real material in both hands and traded it for a man’s bedroom, a man’s medical history, and a sneer at a continent. The bedroom detail is the giveaway. Once a so-called diplomatic critique detours into a marriage bed, the reader has been told the truth about the piece, whether the writer meant to or not. It exists to wound. It was never corrective. It was never educative. It does not even pretend to persuade the subject of anything, because the subject is not the audience. The audience is the mob, and the mob wants blood, not argument.
The high commissioner’s conduct can be debated. The President’s record can be attacked. But a rejoinder is not owed to them. It is owed to the reader. The reader deserves criticism that corrects, educates, or informs. Adelakun’s columns do none of these things. They are written to attack. And by going personal, she has gone too far. But the deeper offence is that she called it analysis.
The Short Answer
Criticism is vital to any democracy, and public officials must always answer for their actions. However, when a column abandons ideas for personal abuse and substitutes self-loathing generalisations for serious thought, it stops informing the public. It becomes mere noise.
So here is the short answer. Ramaphosa did the right thing. He called the news anchor. He corrected the error. The Presidency published the full video. Nigeria did the right thing. His Excellency Fani-Kayode did the right thing by choosing diplomacy over noise. All true Africans owed those killed in South Africa a duty to speak and act. House Negros and Aunt Thomasinas like Adelakun should watch and shut the hell up.
The saddest part is that the talent is visible. The prose is controlled. The allusions are real. A writer this equipped, if she had convictions, could be formidable. But conviction is expensive. It costs you consistency. It costs you the ability to praise what you once condemned and condemn what you once praised. She has never once paid that price. Meanness is cheaper, and it never asks for receipts.
Abimbola Adelakun did not publish two pieces on Fani-Kayode and Tinubu. She pushed two confessions about a byline that has made its peace with cruelty and mistook the peace for principle.
Ademola Rabiu, CEng
Cape Town | 19 November 2026

